Critical Essay #1 (15%)
Critical Essay #2 (15%)
Attentive
participation in lecture, serious reading of the course texts, and vigorous
seminar discussion will constitute the primary activity of this course. As
a result, regular attendance
and vigorous class participation (explained below) will count for 15% of your course grade
(5% for attendance in lecture, 5% for attendance in seminar, and 5% for class
participation in each).
In
addition, this course requires two 1250-word (4-5 pp.) critical essays and one 1750-word (6-8 pp.) final
paper.
Your critical essays and final paper will be argumentative, analytical papers
responding to a question (or questions) which the instructors will provide
for you. These essays can draw upon materials discovered through outside research
but they are not designed to be research papers. If you do consult outside
materials be sure to document them thoroughly with footnotes and a bibliography
(see scholastic dishonesty below). Careful study and use of the weekly course
materials, however, will provide ample and sufficient material for your critical
essays. Further details concerning each assignment will be presented later
in the semester. I encourage you to avail yourself of every opportunity to
consult with me or your seminar instructor about all of your written work.
The two in-term, critical essays will each count 15% of your final grade,
and the final essay (which will cover the whole semester) will count 30% of
your final grade.
Papers
can be turned in at any time up to the dates indicated on the syllabus
and the assignment sheet; after these dates, they will be considered late
papers.
Please note the due dates now so as to plan in advance for any conflicts
with other assignments you may have in other courses. Grades will be lowered
on late papers and after a certain time they may not be accepted at all. Extensions
will not be given unless you have a serious medical problem, nor will incompletes
be allowed except in extreme circumstances.
Academic
integrity is essential to a positive teaching and learning environment. All
students enrolled in University courses are therefore expected to complete
coursework with fairness and honesty. Failure to do so by seeking unfair advantage
over others or misrepresenting someone elseís work as your own, can result
in disciplinary action. The University Student Conduct Code defines scholastic
dishonesty as follows:
Scholastic Dishonesty: submission of false records
of academicachievement; cheating on
assignments or examinations; plagiarizing;altering, forging, or misusing a University academic record; taking,
acquiring, or using test materials without faculty permission; acting alone
or in cooperation with another to falsify records or to obtain dishonestly
grades, honors, awards, or professional endorsement.
Within
this course, a student responsible for scholastic dishonesty can be assigned
a penalty up to and including an "F" for the
course. If you have any questions regarding the expectations for a specific
assignment or exam, be sure to ask.
You
will also be required to deliver at least one oral presentation in your seminar. Your seminar instructor
will describe the requirements of this assignment in your seminar. Your grade
for your oral presentation will contribute 5% to your semester grade.
Finally,
since this course is designated as ìWriting Intensiveî there will be a number
of other assignments which meet the requirements of this designation. Most
important, you will produce a thorough re-write of one (and only one) of your in-term
essays. You will be free to chose which critical essay you would like to re-write,
and the deadline for submitting your re-written essay is Friday, April 25
before 5:00 PM. You must turn in the original draft of your essay with your instructorís
comments on it to receive credit for your re-write. It is your responsibility
to make sure you save the original, graded drafts of your essays and to return
them to the instructor with your re-write at the required time. In deciding
which version of your critical essay to count in your final grade calculation,
your instructor will take the better of the two grades. No averaging of the
two grades will occur. To insure that you nevertheless devote yourself diligently
to the re-write process, a separate grade will be given evaluating your effort and performance
in the re-write process. Your seminar instructor will explain the details
of this requirement. Your grade for your work in re-writing your essay will
count 10% toward your semester grade.
In
addition, you will have a variety of different weekly writing assignments in this course. These assignments
will be determined by your seminar instructor and each of these assignments
is required. Your work on these assignments will be evaluated collectively,
and your grade for your weekly writing will count 10% toward your semester
grade.
Your
class participation
grade will include the following: regular preparation for class, including
bringing the required texts and supplies with you; serious preparation of
the assigned texts; and a sustained effort at contributing to the class discussion
through visible attention, helpful questions and worthwhile insights into
the issues being discussed. In addition, you will occasionally be asked to
prepare class in a special way, or to do other work above and beyond the standard
course requirements described above. All of this work is required and its
quality will be factored into your class participation grade. If you miss
class, it is your responsibility to determine what assignment you may have
missed and make arrangements to complete it in a timely fashion. Feel free
to contact your seminar instructor directly if you feel you may have missed
something. Your class participation grade will contribute 5% to your semester
grade.
You can use
the self-assessment questionnaire below to understand how you are doing as a class participant.Please
consider it from time to time as we go through the course and feel free to
share your evaluation with your seminar instructor (this is not necessary,
but always welcome): Are you prepared for our discussions?Do you participate regularly?Rarely?Do you listen to your
fellow students and respond to them?Do you ask them questions?How do you evaluate the quality of your contributions?Do they spark our discussion?Do you participate actively in group activities?Raise
significant questions?Challenge our
understanding of the texts?Offer insightful
and unexpected reactions to a text?How does your participation compare to that of other students?
Use the
guidelines below to determine what grade you would give yourself for class
participation:
A participation grade falls in the ìCî range if the student
meets the basic requirements of the course: you are present, are usually prepared,
and participate once in a while but not regularly.Your contributions relate to the texts and offer
some insightful ideas, but they rarely facilitate a discussion. You are an
attentive listener.
A participation grade falls in the ìBî range if the student
is involved and motivated in more than the required way: you are always present,
well-prepared, contribute quite regularly by sharing your insights. Your contributions
show that you are familiar with the material.You have good ideas and share them with others.You
also refer to materials discussed in class and to the text, and show interest
in the contributions of other students. You listen to what others say and occasionally try to respond to their
ideas.You help to
create a welcoming atmosphere for peopleís ideas.
A participation grade falls in the ìAî range if the student
not only participates regularly but also consistently and actively encourages
the flow and substance of discussion.You are not only well-prepared, but you also
have thoughts about the texts that go beyond a basic understanding of the
work. You also take responsibility for creating and maintaining a stimulating
discussion each week. You are eager to share your ideas with others, and active
in your listening and reactions to other studentís comments. Your ideas are
critical and stimulate our discussion. When there is a silence or lull in
the conversation, you work hard to move discussion in a new direction. You
are aware of your role in encouraging other students and you work hard to
make classroom discussions an interactive conversation not just a forum for
announcing viewpoints. You help to create a welcoming atmosphere for peopleís
ideas and you listen actively.
The
University defines grades
in the following manner:
A: Achievement that is outstanding
relative to the level necessary to meet the course requirements.
B: Achievement that is significantly
above the level necessary to meet course requirements.
C: Achievement that meets the course requirements
in every respect.
D: Achievement that is worthy of
credit even though it fails to meet fully the course requirements.
F: Represents failure (or no credit)
and signifies that the work was either: (1) completed but at a level of achievement
that is not worthy of credit; or (2) was not completed and there was no agreement
between the instructor and the student that the student would be awarded an
ìI.î
I (Incomplete): Assigned at the discretion
of the instructor when, due to extraordinary circumstances, e.g. hospitalization,
a student is prevented from completing the work of the course on time. Requires
a written agreement between the instructor and the student.
Attendance at every class is required. Problems
do arise, however, and I ask that you notify your seminar instructor in advance
(or even after the fact if it is appropriate) about why you are unable to
attend any class meeting. Of course, unforeseen problems do arise and you
may need to miss class unexpectedly. This need not be a problem. But any more
than three absences from class will lower your grade for attendance in lecture
and seminar. If forces beyond your control do force you to miss more than
three classes, opportunities for make-up work will be available. It is your
responsibility to inquire about these opportunities and to take advantage
of them.
Regarding
Students with Documented Disabilities: Any student with a documented disability
condition (e.g. physical, learning, psychiatric, vision, hearing, etc.) who
needs to arrange reasonable accommodations must contact the instructor and
Disability Services at the beginning of the semester.
Active reading and listening is crucial to success in this course.Each of you will find ways of reading and listening actively that best suit you, but here are some sensible, standard suggestions:
·
Take Notes.Actively
writing down ideas or insights not only preserves them for future reference
on essays and other assignments, it also helps you to engage in active learning
of the topic at hand. You are thus encouraged to keep a notebook for both
lecture and seminar and to use note-taking as much as possible as an active
learning strategy. Reading notes are also encouraged for precisely the same
reason.
·
Use your book.Arm
yourself with a pencil or pen (not a highlighter!) as you read.Underline quotations, write comments, star passages that you wish
to return to for further thought.Record important references and thoughts in your reading notes.
·
Pay attention to your
own responses.When a book moves
or delights you, ask yourself why.When you get bored or irritated with a book,
ask yourself why.Note the passages
which puzzle you, whether it's a logical inconsistency, an absence of credible
evidence, a questionable conclusion, or an assumption that seems implausible.Jot
down in your reading notes questions related to these moments, and plan on
bringing them up in discussion seminar.Remember
that whether you enjoy a text or not cannot be the only judgment you make
regarding it.
·Question
as you read.Challenge the authorís
claims whenever possible. Have they convinced you? Why or why not? What
questions are not posed and what others are left unanswered? What claims
does the author assume? Are they valid? How would different assumptions
alter the argument of the text? Try to connect your questions to specific
passages in the text so that you can point these out to classmates.